Community Health Systems (CHS) Breach Brings New Focus on Network Security

March 31, 2014

The recent systems breach at Community Health Systems (CHS) is a wakeup call for all medical practices to take a closer look at the strength of their network security. Virtually every medical practice utilizes some degree of Electronic Protected Health Information (ePHI) in their day-to-day operations. For example, ePHI may be contained in network servers, electronic health record systems (EHR), practice management systems, and billing records, in addition to the equipment that creates, maintains, transmits or stores ePHI. Even practices that were previously exempt from HIPAA are considered covered entities under Texas law and must protect patient data.

CSO Online, a website that provides news, analysis and research on security topics, is reporting that the Heartbleed bug is to blame for the CHS breach. In April 2014, TMLT first alerted policyholders about the dangers of the Heartbleed Bug and encouraged all practices to assess possible vulnerabilities resulting from this threat.

In wake of the CHS breach, Tony Nelson, CISSP with Artanis Solutions, Inc. has a few practical tips for practices and their IT or network administrators to consider:

Firewall Security is minimum protection for your network and an integral part of your overall defense-in-depth network security:
- Ensure your firewall rules are up-to-date and documented.
- Configure your firewall to send alerts of suspicious network traffic to your IT/network staff (e.g. suspicious network traffic).
- Firewall logs should be routinely reviewed by IT/network administrators.
Consider technology advances to detect and prevent network intrusion. Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) and Intrusion Prevention Systems (IPS) monitor and respond to potential malicious activity on your network.
Consider encryption of data at rest on your servers. Even if your network was hacked, an encrypted server would not allow protected or sensitive data to be accessed in a usable format.
Consider penetration testing. Penetration testing should be done annually to detect issues with network security.

The HIPAA Security Rule contains three categories of safeguard, outlined in the Security Matrix below:

Administrative
Physical
Technical

Each safeguard has a number of security standards that must be met by medical practices and their Business Associates. The HIPAA Security Rule requires a covered entity to comply with the safeguards and standards. Together with reasonable and appropriate Administrative and Physical Safeguards, successful implementation of the Technical Safeguards standards will help ensure that a covered entity will protect the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of ePHI.

The following Security Matrix is found in many HHS publications.

ADMINISTRATIVE SAFEGUARDS
Standards	Sections	Implementation Specifications (R)= Required, (A)=Addressable
Security Management Process	§ 164.308(a)(1)	Risk Analysis	(R)
		Risk Management	(R)
		Sanction Policy	(R)
		Information System Activity Review	(R)
		Information System Activity Review
Assigned Security Responsibility	§ 164.308(a)(2)
Workforce Security	§ 164.308(a)(3)	Authorization and/or Supervision	(A)
		Workforce Clearance Procedure	(A)
		Termination Procedures	(A)
Information Access Management	§ 164.308(a)(4)	Isolating Health Care Clearinghouse Functions	(R)
		Access Authorization	(A)
		Access Establishment and Modification	(A)
Security Awareness and Training	§ 164.308(a)(5)	Security Reminders	(A)
		Protection from Malicious Software	(A)
		Protection from Malicious Software
		Log-in Monitoring	(A)
		Password Management	(A)
Security Incident Procedures	§ 164.308(a)(6)	Response and Reporting	(R)
Contingency Plan	§ 164.308(a)(7)	Data Backup Plan	(R)
		Disaster Recovery Plan	(R)
		Emergency Mode Operation Plan	(R)
		Emergency Mode Operation Plan
		Testing and Revision Procedures	(A)
		Applications and Data Criticality Analysis	(A)
Evaluation	§ 164.308(a)(8)
Business Associate Contracts and Other Arrangements	§ 164.308(b)(1)	Written Contract or Other Arrangement	(R)

PHYSICAL SAFEGUARDS
Standards	Sections	Implementation Specifications (R)= Required, (A)=Addressable
Facility Access Controls	§ 164.310(a)(1)	Contingency Operations	(A)
		Facility Security Plan	(A)
		Access Control and Validation Procedures	(A)
		Access Control and Validation Procedures
		Maintenance Records	(A)
Workstation Use	§ 164.310(b)
Workstation Security	§ 164.310(c)
Device and Media Controls	§ 164.310(d)(1)	Disposal	(R)
		Media Re-use	(R)
		Accountability	(A)
		Data Backup and Storage	(A)
TECHNICAL SAFEGUARDS
Standards	Sections	Implementation Specifications (R)= Required, (A)=Addressable
Access Control	§ 164.312(a)(1)	Unique User Identification	(R)
		Emergency Access Procedure	(R)
		Emergency Access Procedure
		Automatic Logoff	(A)
		Encryption and Decryption	(A)
Audit Controls	§ 164.312(b)
Integrity	§ 164.312(c)(1)	Mechanism to Authenticate Electronic Protected Health Information	(A)
Person or Entity Authentication	§ 164.312(d)
Transmission Security	§ 164.312(e)(1)	Integrity Controls	(A)
Transmission Security	§ 164.312(e)(1)	Encryption	(A)
ORGANIZATIONAL REQUIREMENTS
Standards	Sections	Implementation Specifications (R)= Required, (A)=Addressable
Business associate contracts or other arrangements	§ 164.314(a)(1)	Business Associate Contracts	(R)
Business associate contracts or other arrangements	§ 164.314(a)(1)	Other Arrangements	(R)
Requirements for Group Health Plans	§ 164.314(b)(1)	Implementation Specifications	(R)

POLICIES AND PROCEDURES AND DOCUMENTATION REQUIREMENTS
Standards	Sections	Implementation Specifications (R)= Required, (A)=Addressable
Policies and Procedures	§ 164.316(a)
Documentation	§ 164.316(b)(1)	Time Limit	(R)
		Availability	(R)
		Updates	(R)

TMLT formed the Product Development and Consulting Services department to respond to changes in the health care industry and physician practice needs.

TMLT has invested tremendous resources in our claims and risk management services to provide expert advice to our insured physicians. One of the primary objectives of our department is to expand the access to this expertise on a fee-based consulting basis – with current policyholders and prospective clients – including developing new products to meet evolving medical professional liability market needs.

TMLT is ready to help physician practices meet with their To Do List as needed.

To Do List	Solution
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES - REVIEW AND UPDATE HIPAA and Texas Medical Privacy and Security require you to have updated policies and procedures	TMLT Privacy and Security Toolkit The toolkit guides practices with existing policies through a review and highlights what revisions need to be made. It also guides practices, just developing policies and procedures, to understand the HIPAA rules and Texas law.
NOTICE OF PRIVACY PRACTICES (NPP) - REVIEW AND UPDATE Recent changes to HIPAA (Omnibus Rule) and Texas Medical Privacy and Security require you to revise your Notice of Privacy Practices	Notice of Privacy Practices An important document that tells your patients how you will use and disclose their protected health information (PHI). Changes with Omnibus require you to review and revise your NPP. Changes to Texas law require you to notify patients if you electronically disclose PHI.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATE (BA) & BUSINESS ASSOCIATE AGREEMENT (BAA) - IDENTIFY ALL BAs & REVIEW AND REVISE BAAs BAs are now held to the same requirements under HIPAA as Covered Entities (CE)	Business Associates and Business Associate Agreements Identify all your BAs, anyone who you share your PHI with. Determine if you had an existing BAA with them prior to March 26, 2013 à if yes, you have until September 22, 2014 to get an updated BAA signed. If you did not have a BAA, get one signed as soon as possible. Learn more about BAs and BAAs in TMLT’s Privacy and Security Toolkit.
SECURITY RISK ANALYSIS	TMLT staff can conduct a Security Risk Analysis for your practice. Security Rule requires a Risk Analysis if you do electronic billing or have EHR. Meaningful Use requires a Risk Analysis annually.
TRAINING Physician and Staff HIPAA Training	TMLT Privacy and Security Toolkit Includes “Introduction to Developing Physician Office Training”. TMLT can develop training for your office. Texas law is more stringent than Federal Law on training.
KNOW YOUR STATE LAW	TMLT Privacy and Security Toolkit The Comparison Tool highlights Texas and federal law differences.

To Do List

Solution

POLICIES AND PROCEDURES - REVIEW AND UPDATE

HIPAA and Texas Medical Privacy and Security require you to have updated policies and procedures

TMLT Privacy and Security Toolkit

The toolkit guides practices with existing policies through a review and highlights what revisions need to be made.
It also guides practices, just developing policies and procedures, to understand the HIPAA rules and Texas law.

NOTICE OF PRIVACY PRACTICES (NPP) - REVIEW AND UPDATE

Recent changes to HIPAA (Omnibus Rule) and Texas Medical Privacy and Security require you to revise your Notice of Privacy Practices

Notice of Privacy Practices

An important document that tells your patients how you will use and disclose their protected health information (PHI).
Changes with Omnibus require you to review and revise your NPP.
Changes to Texas law require you to notify patients if you electronically disclose PHI.

BUSINESS ASSOCIATE (BA) & BUSINESS ASSOCIATE AGREEMENT (BAA) - IDENTIFY ALL BAs & REVIEW AND REVISE BAAs

BAs are now held to the same requirements under HIPAA as Covered Entities (CE)

Business Associates and Business Associate Agreements

Identify all your BAs, anyone who you share your PHI with.
Determine if you had an existing BAA with them prior to March 26, 2013 à if yes, you have until September 22, 2014 to get an updated BAA signed.
If you did not have a BAA, get one signed as soon as possible.
Learn more about BAs and BAAs in TMLT’s Privacy and Security Toolkit.

SECURITY RISK ANALYSIS

TMLT staff can conduct a Security Risk Analysis for your practice.
Security Rule requires a Risk Analysis if you do electronic billing or have EHR.
Meaningful Use requires a Risk Analysis annually.

TRAINING

Physician and Staff HIPAA Training

TMLT Privacy and Security Toolkit

Includes “Introduction to Developing Physician Office Training”.
TMLT can develop training for your office.
Texas law is more stringent than Federal Law on training.

KNOW YOUR STATE LAW

TMLT Privacy and Security Toolkit

The Comparison Tool highlights Texas and federal law differences.

For additional information on TMLT’s Toolkit, Risk Analysis or consulting services; call Stephanie Downing at 1-800-580-8658.

AHA and ACCME Provide Ebola Education Package for Healthcare Providers and Institutions

The Ebola education package contains information about the safe management of patients with the disease in ...

AMA Assembles Convenient Location for Latest Ebola Information

The American Medical Association has assembled an Ebola Resource Center so physicians and the public have o...

Community Health Systems (CHS) Breach Brings New Focus on Network Security

Previous Article

Next Article

Community Health Systems (CHS) Breach Brings New Focus on Network Security

Previous Article

Next Article

Most Recent Articles

A compilation of medical malpractice claim data from January 1, 2006 to December 31, 2015, submitted by member companies of the Medical Professional Liability Association (MPL Association).

Texas physicians will be required to use a new system to submit death certificates beginning January 1, 2019.

Texas physicians will be required to use new schedule II prescription forms beginning June 1, 2019.

The TMDP has revised the lists of medical and surgical procedures that require the disclosure of specific risks and informed consent.

It is imperative to have a system in place that allows the release of complete, legible, and organized records from your medical office.

During the current "boil water advisory," Austin residents are encouraged to boil water before drinking or cooking. Daily routines, such as hand washing and bathing, require a little planning.

The TMLT Scholarship was established to recognize Texas medical students who are interested in finding creative and effective ways to enhance patient safety.

Anthem will pay $16 million after cyber attacks exposed the ePHI of 79 million people

TMLT policyholders will receive a 10 percent dividend when they renew their policies in 2019.

Millennials are now the largest segment of our population, and they bring a different set of expectations and needs to health care than previous generations.

According to the FBI, human trafficking is the third-largest criminal activity in the world. (1) A form of human slavery, human trafficking is an estimated $32 billion a year industry.

Texas Governor issues proclamation marking the 15th anniversary of Texas medical liability reforms

Improper disposal of electronic devices and media puts the information stored on those devices at risk for a breach. And when devices contain protected health information (PHI), it puts your patient’s

The story of TMLT

MD Anderson Cancer Center was recently fined for HIPAA violations. Let's go behind the headlines and take a look at the case.

Recent events and reports offer a reminder that effective suicide prevention resources are available to the public and to health care providers for sharing with their patients.

The FDA has approved new labeling for the Orbera and ReShape balloon systems.

Allergan recalls sample packs of Taytulla birth control pills

For this year’s spring CME seminars, attorney Brett B. Rowe presented “How to Fight the Opioid Epidemic” in Austin and Houston. Here’s a brief recap with five risk management takeaways for physicians.

The financial impact of a data breach can be much greater than expected.